Addressing Quality and Manufacturability Challenges of Mission-Critical Products
August 21, 2015 | Amy Yin Chen, NaprotekEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
Typically, mission-critical military and aerospace printed circuit board assemblies (PCBAs) are based on 100% surface mount technology (SMT) and optimized for manufacturability from day one of design. The reality is that many of these products utilize mixed technology, either due to legacy designs or concerns about the interconnection strength of SMT connectors or other critical parts which may be subject to significant shock or vibration. Use of different soldering formulations can drive challenges in meeting cleanliness standards. In many cases, these mixed technology designs often violate industry-standard design guidelines, creating manufacturability issues.
From a contract manufacturing perspective, the first option is to make design for manufacturability (DfM) recommendations for changes to the design that would correct issues that are likely to drive production defects. This is not always a viable option, especially with legacy products or products that have gone through an extensive qualification process. Consequently, the best OEM-contract manufacturing relationships in this area focus not only on eliminating issues that drive defects before they happen, but also have the flexibility to deliver superior quality even when redesign isn’t possible. To better outline issues that should be closely watched in the design process, here are seven of the most common and potential options for addressing them:
Mismatched Footprints: PCB design library footprints don’t always match the specified component footprints, which can impact solderability on components with improperly sized pads. It can also contribute to additional defects when spacing among SMT and through-hole components is tight. Footprint accuracy should always be checked as part of the design review process.
If the design isn’t changed prior to prototyping, the appropriate approach is to manually place the parts and provide feedback to the customer on the issues. When the component is an integrated circuit, it is bonded pin 1 to pin 1. The preferred option is that the PCB be re-laid out or the bill of materials modified.
Failure to Provide Proper Spacing/Clearance for Through-Hole Components: Mixed technology, double-sided boards are often run on pallets through the wave solder in order to protect any bottom-side components that can’t be exposed to the wave. This issue can also make it difficult to use automated insertion equipment. Use of IPC design guidelines can help the design team to avoid this issue.
The recommended clearance for fixturing is 75 mils. However, as products shrink, many PCB designers are going to 35 mils.
Editor's Note: This article originally appeared in the August 2015 issue of SMT Magazine.
Suggested Items
Indium Corporation to Present, Exhibit at EPP InnovationsFORUM
03/28/2024 | Indium CorporationIndium Corporation is set to present and exhibit at EPP InnovationsFORUM, one of Europe’s premier single-day electronics manufacturing forums, on April 17 in Leinfelden-Echterdingen, Germany. Topic areas for 2024 will include AI, automation, sustainability, and quality.
Reducing Nitrogen Consumption in Convection Soldering with Rehm Thermal Systems' Patented Mechatronic Curtain
03/28/2024 | Rehm Thermal SystemsCurrent developments indicate a need for larger throughput heights due to the trend towards e-mobility, which in turn increases nitrogen consumption for process inertization. Rehm Thermal Systems responds to this issue with an innovative solution: the mechatronic curtain.
Indium Corporation, Industry Partners to Showcase Products “Live@APEX”
03/26/2024 | Indium CorporationIndium Corporation®, in cooperation with its industry partners, will feature its proven solder solutions live on the show floor throughout IPC APEX Expo from Apr. 9‒11 in Anaheim, Calif., U.S.
ITW EAE Wins New Product Introduction Award for Electrovert® Wave Soldering Machine Deep Wave
03/26/2024 | ITW EAEITW EAE is proud to announce that it has earned a 2024 New Product Introduction (NPI) Award for Electrovert’s Deep Wave option for wave soldering machines. This new, innovative system provides the ability to pump up to a 20 mm wave height.
Mek's Next-Gen AOI Technology Takes Center Stage at IPC APEX EXPO 2024
03/19/2024 | MEKMek is excited to announce its presence at IPC APEX EXPO, North America's largest electronics manufacturing event, in Anaheim, California, from April 6-11, 2024. Attendees are invited to visit Mek at booth #1433 to explore the latest AOI technology offerings.